Types of product prototypes: a complete guide to choosing yours

From the minimum viable prototype to the pre-industrial one: what each type proves, when to use it and what it costs to get the stage wrong.

Respuesta corta

What types of prototypes are there?

There are seven main types: minimum viable prototype, pretotype, homemade prototype, 3D prototype, mock-up, functional prototype and pre-industrial prototype. They are grouped by what you want to prove (the idea, technical feasibility or costs) and also by the industry they target.

Define which uncertainty you want to eliminate and you will find the type of prototype that fits best. To see how much yours costs, use the prototype price calculator.

Types of prototypes according to the priorities of the process

Prototypes help minimize uncertainty in the innovation process. Define what you want to prove and you will find the type that fits best.

Fase 1

Prototypes for Idea Validation

Defining the business opportunity. These prototypes must be very lightweight: the aim is to prove that a real, unsolved problem exists in the market.

Types that fit: PMV, pretotipo

Fase 2

Prototypes for Technical Validation

The aim is to eliminate the main points of technical uncertainty surrounding the invention. These are somewhat more complex prototypes with some research load.

Types that fit: casero, 3D, maqueta, funcional

Fase 3

Prototypes for cost optimization

These are prototypes very close to the final product. They aim to prove the industrial feasibility of the product.

Types that fit: preindustrial

Comparison table of types of prototypes

What each type proves and where its limits are.

Comparison of the seven types of product prototypes
Type of prototypeObjetivo principalWhat is testedWhat it does not solve
Minimum viable prototype (MVP)Prove that the problem exists in more peopleMarket interest, with a video, a landing page or another mediumIt does not show the real product
PretotipoMeasure the customer’s reaction to a simulation of the solutionAcceptance of the solution, with the customer nearbyIt is not a working product
Prototipo caseroA first approach to the functionsFunctional requirements of the inventionIt does not validate technical or economic feasibility
Prototipo 3DVisualize the concept realisticallyCustomer reaction and ergonomics before it existsIt does not guarantee it works or that the components are the final ones
Product mock-upPhysical representation of the shapeErgonomics, size, weight and cost of the casingsIt is not functional and gives no industrialization prices
Functional prototypeProve technical feasibilityThat the invention works, its ergonomics in use and customers’ general reactionIt still does not allow defining the price of the final product
Prototipo preindustrialDetermine industrial manufacturing pricesDocumentation to manufacture at scale and market acceptanceIt requires having gone through the previous stages
TYPE 1 · IDEA

Minimum viable prototype (MVP): what it is and examples

The minimum viable prototype is not a representative version of the idea. Its only goal is to prove that the problem the inventor has identified exists in other people and is not suffered by them alone.

An MVP can be a video, a landing page or another useful medium to describe the idea’s value proposition and measure the reaction of users or potential customers.

MVP example: Dropbox

After a resounding failure in developing a product, Dropbox’s founders learned the importance of measuring customer behavior before investing tens of thousands of dollars. They launched a video explaining the value proposition of the future platform and how it would solve the problem of file inaccessibility, all before starting to develop the software.

The MVP in video format let them measure indicators that revealed the connection between their idea and the interests of their potential customers.

TYPE 2 · IDEA

The Pretotype as a Type of Prototype

The pretotype is an experiment that simulates, in a natural setting, the situation in which users face a problem, so they can see and experience the solution in a “simulated” way. This measures their behavior toward the solution the future prototype or product will deliver.

Difference from the MVP: the MVP can communicate the solution through any medium; the pretotype communicates the value proposition with the customer nearby and also simulates the operation of a product similar to the idea.

Objectives of the pre-prototype

Measure customers’ reaction to a simulated response to a specific problem. This way we will know not only that the problem exists, but that the chosen path to a solution is accepted by potential customers.

Example: IBM’s “Speech to text” experiment

IBM presented at a trade fair a machine able to turn any dictation into text. To validate customer interest before developing it, it brought a large device with a human inside who typed in real time what the participants said. It was enough to prove the interest the solution aroused.

Historical engraving of the Mechanical Turk, an automaton with a person hidden inside
A person inside the machine: the idea of the pretotype
TYPE 3 · TECHNICAL

Homemade prototypes: what they are, goals and examples

A homemade prototype is the handmade version of the product that inventors usually build to show that their idea works and solves a real problem. They are made with existing materials, adapted by hand by the inventor: an unprofessional but very important prototype, because it is the first approach to the functions.

Although it is important, it should not be confused with the technical and economic feasibility of the prototype: those aspects must be validated and optimized professionally by product design and development experts.

What homemade prototypes can I manufacture?

Inventors can build different versions of homemade prototypes, especially of mechanical products and household appliances. They are not ready to approach industry, because their components are usually not optimal for mass production.

What is a homemade prototype used for?

It serves to convey the functional requirements of the prototype. By analyzing the characteristics of the homemade prototype, the main goals of the innovative product are defined, and the inventor can express with more certainty what they want to achieve in the product creation cycle.

TYPE 4 · TECHNICAL

3D prototypes: what they are and what they are for

A 3D prototype is a conceptual design of the idea. With 3D design and mechanical development tools, a very realistic concept of the product is created. But it does not guarantee that the prototype works or that its components and mechanisms are the final ones: it should be used as a guide, never as a restriction. Copying it exactly can hold back improvements during manufacturing and in the basic engineering project.

Objectives of the 3D prototype

It offers a realistic view of the innovative product to measure customers’ reaction and behavior toward it before it exists. It lets you learn from their comments to improve ergonomics and understand their expectations. It is worth designing more than one 3D prototype to compare reactions, especially regarding the expected ergonomics.

Example of a 3D prototype

Our 3D design team and our functional prototype manufacturing team work hand in hand. We are currently designing a pet leash with a water tank, a liquid dispensing system and a bag tank for picking up waste. Making all these subsystems coexist is an ergonomics challenge: the shape, colors and dimensions are highly debatable decisions for which it is essential to know the customers’ view.

The 3D prototype in the images will surely undergo important improvements after its first impact on customers.

3D prototype of a pet leash, version 1
3D prototype of a pet leash, version 2
3D prototype of a pet leash, version 3
TYPE 5 · TECHNICAL

Product mock-ups: goals and examples

The mock-up, or mock-up prototype, is not the functional prototype. It is a physical representation of the product’s shape, which lets customers and the inventor touch and handle it before integrating the mechanisms that provide functionality.

With it you determine ergonomics, analyze feasibility according to size and weight and estimate the cost of making the outer casings. It does not reveal industrialization prices: that is a goal of pre-industrial prototypes.

Mock-ups are built with 3D printing, laser cutting and other modern techniques, and they must be cheap and easy to modify, because they are a very experimental initial prototype.

Goals of the mock-up

Determine ergonomics by simulating usage examples. As with the 3D prototype, it is worth making several mock-ups with different shapes and colors to compare customer feedback.

Examples of mock-ups

These mock-ups were made with 3D printing and commercial components. With them the client was able to validate the ergonomics and the expectation it creates among future customers. At this stage it is still too early to patent the idea.

Mock-up of a transparent medical cube for healthcare products
Mock-up of an invention for medicine
TYPE 6 · TECHNICAL

Functional prototypes: goals, examples and advantages

The functional prototype includes the systems and subsystems that make the product work. With it, the inventor shows investors and potential customers that the invention works, although the price of the final product still cannot be defined. It also provides enough information about ergonomics in use and allows drafting the patent specification to protect the innovation claims.

Conviene fabricarlo before filing the patent: during the process you obtain improvements that lower future industrial manufacturing costs, improve ergonomics and let you analyze market behavior. Its price depends on variables very different from materials; see the prototype price calculator.

Objectives of the Functional Prototype

Prove the invention’s technical feasibility, measure ergonomics in use and customers’ general reaction. It does not aim to make money selling units, but to measure market acceptance.

Best examples of functional prototypes

At Let’s Prototype we have built more than 200 functional prototypes in recent years. See some of the most outstanding ones.

Functional prototype of a shelved display unit, made by Let’s Prototype
Functional prototype example: transparent umbrella with mechanism
TYPE 7 · COSTS

Pre-industrial prototypes: definition, goals and examples

The pre-industrial prototype is a very advanced version of the product. It cannot be built without going through the previous stages: the product creation cycle is a continuous, non-linear learning process. Once enough has been learned, the pre-industrial prototype lets you analyze the techniques available to industrialize the product and manufacture it at scale, and determine the manufacturing steps and their costs.

Goals of the pre-industrial prototype

  • Determine the industrial manufacturing prices of the product.
  • Learn about the acceptance of the functional prototype.
  • Determine the documentation needed to manufacture at scale.

That documentation includes the BOM (a detailed list of all components) and the drawing set for the parts. With it, industrial methods and suppliers are explored, and the business plan and the mass-production price of the product are prepared.

Example: IoT device for cigar humidors

Relative humidity determines how well cigars keep, and enthusiasts worry about holding it within suitable parameters. We developed an IoT device that connects to the user’s phone, where the acceptable values are set. It stays in low-power mode for hours, wakes up to take a daily reading and, if the environment is not right, alerts the phone with the wrong measurement and some recommendations.

After building several prototypes we reached a pre-industrial one with electronics and an ergonomic design, small enough not to affect the humidor’s capacity. Today it is ready to manufacture at scale and on sale on platforms such as Amazon, a very suitable environment to measure customer acceptance.

Battery-powered IoT device from the pre-industrial prototype for humidors
Custom electronic board (PCB) for the IoT device

Common questions about types of prototypes

What types of prototypes are there?
Seven: minimum viable prototype, pretotype, homemade prototype, 3D prototype, mock-up, functional prototype and pre-industrial prototype. You choose according to what you want to prove: the idea, technical feasibility or costs.
What is the difference between an MVP and a pretotype?
The MVP can communicate the solution through any medium (a video, a landing page) to measure the reaction of potential customers. The pretotype communicates the value proposition with the customer nearby and also simulates the operation of a product similar to the idea.
What is the difference between a mock-up and a functional prototype?
The mock-up is a physical representation of the shape: it is useful for assessing ergonomics, size and weight, but it does not work. The functional prototype includes the systems and subsystems that make the product work and proves its technical feasibility.
When should I patent: before or after the prototype?
At the mock-up stage it is too early to patent. The functional prototype already lets you draft the patent specification, and it is best to build it before filing, because the process yields improvements that are then protected.
How much does a prototype cost?
The price of a functional prototype depends on variables very different from materials, above all the technical uncertainty of the invention. You can get an indicative estimate with the prototype price calculator. Calculate the price of my prototype.
What is a pre-industrial prototype for?
To determine industrial manufacturing prices, learn about the acceptance of the functional prototype and prepare the documentation to manufacture at scale, such as the BOM and the part drawings.

Which type of prototype does your invention need?

Tell us your idea and we will help you choose the next step, with a fixed price.

Iván Bedia García, CEO and technical lead at Let’s Prototype
Erick Remedios, Director of Business Development at Let’s PrototypeTalk to an expert in startups and new business developmentErick Remedios · Director of Business Development